These fish tend to form monogamous pairs that can last throughout their lives. It is noteworthy that Pelvicachromis pulcher is very meticulous in choosing a partner. Thus, if adult male and female are introduced into an aquarium, there is no full guarantee that they will necessarily form a pair. In this regard, when planning breeding, one can choose one of two approaches. The first option involves purchasing about a dozen young individuals, among whom, as they mature, at least one formed pair will almost certainly appear. The second method is to acquire an already established, formed pair. Otherwise, the breeding process of Pelvicachromis pulcher is simple. The beginning of the breeding period is a gradual adjustment of water parameters to the following values: pH 5.5–6.5, dGH 5–10, temperature 23–26°C. The readiness of females for spawning is easily determined by the pink coloration of their abdomen. Having chosen a suitable place, most often a small cave, the female secludes herself there for several days and lays up to 200 eggs. The male, meanwhile, remains at the entrance, guarding the approaches to the spawning site. The incubation period lasts from 2 to 3 days, and after about another week, the fry begin to swim freely, although they stay close to their parents. The female and male jointly continue to care for their offspring.